September 08, 2010, 07:40:11 PM
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News: Welcome to K5TIT's website!

NOTICE:  We have noticed an increase in bot registrations, and have had to make our registration process more stringent.  If you should have problems registering, please email n5ebw at this domain for assistance.  Thanks!
   Home   Help Search Login Register  
Pages: 1 [2]
  Print  
Author Topic: Known Good Routers  (Read 14294 times)
k0rpx
Newbie
*
Posts: 2


View Profile
« Reply #15 on: May 23, 2007, 07:36:31 PM »

Linksys router doesn’t support class A subnetting?  Read on.

Preliminary note #1: Special thanks to Jay Maynard (K5ZC) for providing the information in this thread that made this possible and Nic with the Stafford group, the brave man that bought a brand new router and was prepared to turn it into a doorstop, all for the good of DSTAR!

Preliminary note #2: Although this message appears to speak to one very specific router model, it is probably that similar processes are available for many other router variants using the links provided here.


*** IMPORTANT NOTE
Before you begin, read this document in its entirety.  I can’t be held liable for mistakes encountered through someone’s desire to get it done fast.  In fact, please don’t hold me liable at all!

*** THE ADVENTURE BEGINS
Last weekend we were working on assisting in setting up the WW4VA Gateway and I wanted to run through our router experience in some level of detail with you as this will likely save some DSTAR admins some ca$h, at least for now.
Note: even if you have a working DSTAR gateway, you might want to read this to prepare for the case if/when your current router dies on you.

We confirmed the information in this thread – current LinkSys routers no longer support class A subnetting on the internal side of the network (LAN side) but we know earlier variants of some of the same model numbers (eg: the model recommended by ICOM) did because we are using one on the WW4VA repeater.  Unfortunately, they don’t now.  Obviously the marketing of the lower end router manufacturers (cheapy home routers like Linksys, the cheap line of DLINK, and nameless others) don’t expect that the average user is going to have millions of systems in their house that require unique IP addresses from the router – so for most people class C supporting 255 computers in your house is good enough.

KE5C nails it with his post in this thread so I wanted to go into a bit more detail since we actually had to execute the REMOVAL of the production Linksys firmware in the brand-spanking-new Linksys WR54G Version 6.0 router that Nic bought from Radio Shack.  You are reading this correctly, if you are going to install the homebrew router firmware KE5C mentions (located here: http://www.dd-wrt.com/dd-wrtv2/downloads.php) for this router you MUST following this process for this model of Linksys routers located here: http://scorpiontek.org/portal/content/view/27/36/) .  This process seems very very daunting and dangerous but I can assure you that, at least for the Linksys WR54G Version 6 (and likely several versions of the same model) Router this process is amazingly documented and a beautiful step by step process in:
1.   Remove the existing Linksys firmware from the router
2.   Installation of the homebrew firmware installer as the default load option for the router
3.   Installation of the homebrew firmware available at the DD-WRT website

I should warn you (and the procedure does as well) that you are doing this at your own risk as it, no doubt, voids any warranty you may get with Linksys.  The good news is that it turned our class C only router into a fully functional Class A router and
retains the very same look and feel as the Linksys Firmware with a few new slick features fellow geeks are going to love.  If you download all the files they tell you to ahead of time and ensure you follow the process TO THE LETTER at the scorpiontek.org site you should not have any problems turning that useless class C into a functional class A.
The forums are exceedingly informative on those two sites regarding the various versions of the homebrew firmwares, what routers they support (they support a bunch), and how to install the firmware.

Side note 1: we tried to use the Linksys admin firmware update utility to load the dd-wrt.com firmware (dd-wrt.v23 SP2) directly but it fails because on this model, the Linksys admin firmware install utility appears smart enough to know that the dd-wrt firmware is NOT a Linksys firmware – thus the need to get rid of the Linksys firmware off the device before you can install a new one.  If you try to load the homebrew firmware with the Linksys admin install utility and it fails, don’t worry.  It doesn’t hurt anything.  We tried it about 10 times and it failed every time with various homebrew firmware versions.

Side note 2: some of the steps can take a while to complete so be patient as you could be looking at a “please wait a few minutes” screen for “a few minutes” or more.

Side note 3: if you are not a least a little bit network saavy and know how to change between dynamic DHCP and static IP, are at least marginally familiar with the Linksys (or whatever your router is) firmware screens, and a teeny bit brave, get some help.
Side note 4: after you are done with everything, you may want to reboot everything and power-cycle your router one last time before going for your final DSTAR configuration setup to make sure everything is coming up clean.  Worst case at this point is that you can always reload your original firmware.


*** IMPORTANT NOTE ON THE SCORPIONTEK.ORG PROCEDURE
The procedure has you install the dd-wrt.v23 SP2 generic micro firmware.  This is a very limited firmware, is not router specific, and doesn’t appear to let you save your settings.  Once you have completed the procedure, power-cycled everything, and are in your new firmware configuration screen (the micro generic firmware), you need to now flash in the STANDARD firmware for your router model (v23 SP2 is located here: http://www.dd-wrt.com/dd-wrtv2/downloads.php) using the admin part of the firmware as you normally would.  In fact, now you can flash in just about any firmware you want.
Note: the firmware file names available from dd-wrt reference both the version of the firmware and the model of the router, we just downloaded what appeared the be the latest one and installed that which was the v23 SP2 standard firmware for the WRT54G.
I hope this helps some of you out there in either getting a new DSTAR gateway on the network or formulating a DSTAR hardware recovery plan.

Finally, I would like to express my thanks to Jay, Nic, and the WW4VA club for allowing me to participate in this setup and all the experimentation that went into getting them going.  They should be live on the network shortly and we at the WW4EMC club look forward to further testing with them.

If you would like to chat about this procedure, feel free to contact me on DSTAR or via email.

73,
Scott Harlow
K0RPX
k0rpx@emergencycommunicators.net
DSTAR Admin – WW4EMC repeater (Virginia) – all modules
Logged

 
k0rpx
Newbie
*
Posts: 2


View Profile
« Reply #16 on: May 23, 2007, 07:52:28 PM »

Oh, sorry Nic, didn't get your callsign in the post.

Nick is KI4OQA if you would like to contact him as well.

73,
Scott
K0RPX
Logged

 
N5MIJ
Forum Admin
Administrator
Full Member
*****
Posts: 167


View Profile
« Reply #17 on: May 23, 2007, 07:52:52 PM »

And just for grins, I did a similar thing to an older version WRT54GS that I had laying around from some early experiments.

Works great!  In fact, if I can convince it to be a wireless client, you may see it at the D-STAR Users Meeting at HamCom June 9...

73,
Jim

Jim McClellan
N5MIJ
Logged

Jim McClellan
N5MIJ
K8GLD
Guest
« Reply #18 on: September 11, 2007, 02:27:29 PM »

I am trying to decide which router to purchase in order to get the gateway going here in Michigan.  I attempted to flash the firmware on a newer Linksys, but the WRT54G, Version 8 routers are not yet supported with the DD firmware releases.  I have been considering the Connect Gear GR-104, however locating one from a reputable source has been somewhat of a chore as well.  Does anyone have any suggestions on which router is going to server my purpose and that isn't all that expensive???  I am looking to get something ordered and have it here A.S.A.P.  Thanks,

Trustee: Jerry Dubzak - K8GLD

Livingston County D-Star Group
K8LCD  B
444.0625MHz. +5.00
Logged
n5ebw
Administrator
Jr. Member
*****
Posts: 60


View Profile
« Reply #19 on: September 11, 2007, 03:26:45 PM »

Hi, you should be able to flash it with Open-WRT and make it work.

The reason the newer routers aren't supported is because they don't have enough flash memory to hold the image.  You can, however, install the DD-WRT lite image, I think.  If you are wanting to use DD-WRT with a Linksys router, I suggest the WRT-54GL or WRT-54GS.  Those are the Linux and Speedboost models, and they come with much more on board than the plain G routers.
Logged

....welcome to the FUN.
wa3pnt
Newbie
*
Posts: 14


View Profile WWW
« Reply #20 on: September 11, 2007, 03:30:24 PM »

I have several GR-104 Routers that I've been using without any problems.  Since they operate on 12VDC, I power them from the Shack Power which has a backup.

I went to the ConnectGear Site and used one of their "Where Do I Purchase" merchants.  Here's the link, and I think that I used the Pro Advantage Supplier.

http://www.connectgear.com/wheretobuy.htm

George
Logged

Desert Intertie Network (DIN)
Owner/Builder
k7ve
Newbie
*
Posts: 8


View Profile WWW
« Reply #21 on: December 01, 2007, 10:34:57 AM »

I purchased a Netgear FVS318 for our Salt Lake City gateway that is under construction.  It appears to provide all of the necessary features including Class A network routing (I have it configured on my home network, Net-10, Net-192.168.x.x, Linksys router to Internet and it works fine), and it was less than US$35 delivered from the following URL: http://justdeals.com/Items/fvs318nar?

The manual is at: http://kbserver.netgear.com/pdf/fvs318v3_manual.pdf

This router also has firmware VPN support if you need it.

-- John, K7VE
http://k7ve.ampr.org
Logged

 
wa3pnt
Newbie
*
Posts: 14


View Profile WWW
« Reply #22 on: December 27, 2007, 10:33:01 PM »

I'm kind of late in posting this here, but I did post it on one of the other D-Star Forums.

I was using the Connectgear GR-104 Routers (two in series between the Gateway and the ISP) and received reports that our outgoing audio was "chopping".

I suspected an Upload Speed problem, and worked with my ISP to have that increased.  The problem remained.

Finally I replaced the two GR-104 Routers with two U.S. Robotics USR-8054 Routers and the problem cleared up.  Just to be certain it was the Routers, I put them back on line for a test, and the "chopping" was back.

Another variable for System Admins to look at if they're having audio problems.

George
Logged

Desert Intertie Network (DIN)
Owner/Builder
w5gm
Newbie
*
Posts: 3


View Profile WWW
« Reply #23 on: February 26, 2008, 11:07:42 AM »

Cisco 2611..
2 good points, a)They are rack mount.. B) they will do ANYTHING you want..

Config is a breeze, you can do it with hyperterm or secureCRT if you are a pro..
Logged

Jay Urish -- W5GM
Pages: 1 [2]
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by SMF 1.1.3 | SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines LLC



© Copyright K5TIT - The Texas Interconnect Team. All Rights Reserved.